How to Make Creamy Dairy-Free Jell-O Pudding with Plant Milk (Vegan & Allergy-Friendly)

The back of a Jell-O pudding box explicitly states not to use milk substitutes, but as an adventurous home cook, I’ve always found that rules are sometimes meant to be creatively reinterpreted. For anyone navigating dietary restrictions like dairy allergies, lactose intolerance, or embracing a vegan lifestyle, craving classic treats is a common experience. That’s why I’m thrilled to share my tried-and-true method for making wonderfully rich and creamy Jell-O brand pudding using various milk alternatives, ensuring it’s both allergy-friendly and perfectly vegan.

The journey to a dairy-free lifestyle can be motivated by various factors: nursing mothers seeking to identify sensitivities, individuals exploring specific dietary plans, those embracing veganism, or families managing severe food allergies, like my own. Whatever the reason, transitioning to dairy-free doesn’t mean sacrificing the joy of delicious treats. Chocolate, in particular, often poses a challenge, as most readily available store-bought options typically contain milk. Finding an easy, dairy-free chocolate dessert can feel like a quest.

While I thoroughly enjoy cooking from scratch, the realities of a busy life often demand quick and simple solutions. Sometimes, you just need an easy dessert or a fuss-free after-school snack without spending hours in the kitchen. I used to wistfully gaze at the pudding aisle, wishing my son could enjoy such a simple indulgence. One day, I decided to stop wishing and start experimenting – determined to crack the code for allergy-friendly Jell-O pudding.

My initial attempts were, to put it mildly, a disaster – more akin to chocolate soup than pudding. But through persistence, I discovered the absolute key: it *has* to be the cook and serve variety. The instant pudding mix, unfortunately, will never properly set with plant-based milks. Once I made this crucial switch, the results were transformative: thick, creamy, and utterly delicious. This discovery has made Jell-O pudding a permanent staple in my pantry, ready whenever a quick chocolate craving strikes!

Let’s dive into some common questions about making Jell-O pudding without dairy.

Is Jell-O Pudding Gluten-Free?

For those managing both gluten and dairy sensitivities, you’re in luck! Jell-O pudding, in both its instant and cook and serve varieties, is currently formulated without wheat or gluten. This makes it a fantastic base for many allergy-friendly desserts. Always remember to check the most current ingredient list on the packaging, as formulations can change over time.

What Ingredients Are in Jell-O Instant Pudding?

Understanding the ingredients in your food is essential, especially when managing allergies. Here’s a typical ingredient list for Jell-O instant pudding in chocolate fudge flavor (as noted on their website in November 2019):

• Sugar
• Modified cornstarch (a key thickener)
• Cocoa processed with alkali
• Disodium phosphate (for thickening), contains less than 2% of natural & artificial flavor
• Tetrasodium Pyrophosphate (another thickening agent)
• Mono-and Diglycerides (to prevent foaming and improve texture)
• Red 40, Yellow 5, Blue 1 (artificial colors)
• Artificial Color
• BHA (preservative)

The modified cornstarch and phosphates are what allow instant pudding to set quickly without heat, reacting with the proteins and fats in traditional milk. However, plant-based milks often lack these components, which is why instant pudding struggles to set properly without dairy. As always, verify the ingredients on your box, as recipes can be updated by manufacturers.

What Ingredients Are in Jell-O Cook and Serve Pudding?

Beyond performing better with milk alternatives, Jell-O cook and serve also generally boasts a simpler ingredient list, often without artificial colors, compared to its instant counterpart. This can be a significant draw for those looking for fewer additives in their diet. Below are the ingredients for Jell-O cook and serve pudding in chocolate fudge flavor (as found on their website in November 2019):

• Sugar
• Dextrose
• Cornstarch (the primary thickener that activates with heat)
• Cocoa (processed with Alkali)
• Modified cornstarch
• Contains less than 2% of salt, calcium carrageenan, polysorbate 60, fumaric acid

The reliance on cornstarch and modified cornstarch that requires heat to activate makes the “cook and serve” variety much more adaptable to plant-based milks. Heating these starches causes them to swell and create the desired thick, creamy texture, independent of the specific fat and protein content of the milk. Again, always double-check the packaging for the most current information.

Is Jell-O Pudding Vegan?

A common misconception, which I frequently encounter, is that Jell-O brand pudding cannot be vegan. Many assume that because Jell-O gelatin desserts contain gelatin (an animal-derived product), their pudding mixes must as well. However, this is not the case! As you can see from the ingredient lists for both Jell-O instant pudding mix and cook and serve, neither contains eggs, milk, or any other animal products in the dry mix itself. The magic lies in the thickeners used – primarily cornstarch – not gelatin.

Therefore, the Jell-O pudding mix itself is vegan. The only reason it wouldn’t be vegan is if you prepare it with cow’s milk, as the box instructions traditionally suggest. This is precisely why my recipe, which substitutes dairy milk with plant-based alternatives, is so vital for making a genuinely vegan and dairy-free Jell-O pudding. Refer to the recipe card below for the exact method!

Does Jell-O Pudding Contain Gelatin?

To clarify further, it’s crucial to distinguish between Jell-O’s gelatin desserts and their pudding mixes. Gelatin, which is derived from animal collagen, is indeed what gives traditional Jell-O its characteristic jiggly set. However, Jell-O pudding uses different starches, primarily cornstarch, to achieve its creamy, thick consistency when cooked. This makes the pudding mixes inherently free of gelatin and suitable for vegan diets, provided they are prepared with plant-based milk.

Can You Make Jell-O Pudding with Almond Milk?

Absolutely! If you don’t have nut allergies, almond milk is a popular and readily available option for making Jell-O pudding. You can also successfully use other nut-based milks like cashew milk, or even creamy coconut milk (from a carton, not canned, for best results). While nut milks might impart a subtle hint of their flavor to the final product, many find this enjoyable. My personal favorite is rice milk, as it offers the most neutral flavor profile, leaving no discernible aftertaste.

The single most important factor, regardless of which plant milk you choose, is to use the cook and serve variety, never the instant kind. Plant milks, especially thinner ones like almond milk, simply don’t contain the necessary proteins and fats to activate the instant pudding’s thickeners effectively, often resulting in a runny, unset mixture. I recommend starting with the ratio provided in my recipe card and adjusting the liquid incrementally to achieve your preferred thickness. It’s always easier to add more liquid than to thicken a watery pudding!

Can You Make Jell-O Pudding with Soy Milk?

Yes, soy milk is another excellent option for preparing dairy-free Jell-O pudding, provided you don’t have soy allergies. We’ve used soy milk numerous times with great success. It tends to be thicker and creamier than some other plant milks, which can contribute to a richer pudding texture. However, some individuals might detect a slight “beany” aftertaste, which is why I often prefer rice milk for its more neutral profile.

As with all plant-based milks, the critical rule remains: stick to the cook and serve Jell-O pudding mix. Soy milk, while relatively thick, will still struggle to properly set instant pudding. Begin with the liquid ratio outlined in my recipe card and adjust as needed to reach your ideal pudding consistency.

Can You Make Jell-O Pudding with Rice Milk?

As I’ve mentioned, rice milk is my preferred choice for making dairy-free Jell-O pudding. Its greatest advantage is its wonderfully neutral flavor, which allows the chocolate (or other pudding flavor) to shine through without any distracting aftertastes that can sometimes accompany nut or soy milks. Since my son can consume both rice and soy milk, I occasionally use soy milk if we happen to run out of rice milk, and it works perfectly in a pinch.

Once again, the golden rule applies: always opt for the cook and serve variety. Rice milk, being on the thinner side, is particularly unsuited for the instant kind, which would result in a very runny dessert. Begin with the recommended liquid ratio in my recipe card, and feel free to add small amounts of additional rice milk until you achieve your desired creamy consistency.

How Long Does Rice Milk Last?

Knowing how to store your ingredients is key for meal planning and reducing waste. I’ve encountered two main types of rice milk packaging: shelf-stable boxes and refrigerated cartons. The shelf-stable varieties are typically found in the juice aisle and are excellent for stocking your pantry as a backup; they’ll last until their expiration date, often several months away. Once opened, however, they require refrigeration and usually stay fresh for up to ten days.

Refrigerated cartons of rice milk, found in the dairy or alternative milk section, need to be kept cold from the moment you bring them home. Their shelf life is also generally about ten days after opening, or until the expiration date printed on the package. You’ll know your rice milk has spoiled if it appears chunky or develops an off-smell when poured. If you’re a fan of rice-based desserts, you might also enjoy my gluten-free rice pudding recipe!

Storing Dairy-Free Pudding

Proper storage is essential to keep your homemade dairy-free pudding fresh and delicious. Any pudding not immediately served or consumed should be refrigerated promptly in an airtight container. Alternatively, covering the bowl tightly with plastic cling wrap (saran wrap) will also work to prevent a “skin” from forming on top. Dairy-free pudding typically maintains its quality for up to three days in the refrigerator.

Before serving chilled pudding again, a quick stir is recommended to restore its smooth consistency. If you find the pudding has firmed up more than you prefer after chilling, simply whisk in a teaspoon or so of your chosen non-dairy milk at a time until it reaches your desired creamy texture. This simple trick allows for perfect pudding every time, whether you enjoy it warm or cold.

Do You Want Other Recipes That Use Dairy-Free Jell-O Pudding?

My adapted dairy-free Jell-O pudding recipe isn’t just for eating straight from a bowl; it’s a versatile ingredient that can elevate many other allergy-friendly desserts! Here are some of my favorite recipes that feature this easy-to-make dairy-free pudding:

• Triple Chocolate Pie – This no-bake wonder uses dairy-free Jell-O pudding as its luscious middle layer, making it an absolute breeze to prepare!
• Lemon Cream Pie Bars – Discover how to create vibrant lemon pudding without any milk or eggs for these delightful bars.
• Strawberry Jell-O Pie – A wonderfully light and fruity pie that’s completely gluten and dairy-free!
• Peach Pie – Incorporates Jell-O pudding to really enhance that fresh peach flavor, and it’s gluten-free too!

Creating delicious, allergy-friendly desserts shouldn’t be a struggle. With this simple guide, you can confidently prepare creamy, rich Jell-O pudding using your favorite plant-based milk, making it accessible to everyone, regardless of dietary restrictions. It’s a testament to how small adaptations can bring back beloved comfort foods, proving that being dairy-free or vegan doesn’t mean compromising on taste or convenience. Enjoy this classic treat reimagined for modern dietary needs!

CHECK OUT MY PINTEREST BOARDS FOR OTHER ALLERGY-FRIENDLY IDEAS!

---

Here are my other top dairy-free posts you might find helpful: