The Ultimate Gluten, Dairy & Egg-Free Chicken Salad Sandwich: A Delicious Allergy-Friendly Recipe

Discover how to transform a beloved classic into a truly delicious gluten, dairy, and egg-free chicken salad sandwich. Packed with vibrant flavors, satisfying crunch from sunflower seeds, red onion, celery, and grapes, this recipe proves you don’t have to compromise on taste when managing food allergies. Dive in to learn all the smart substitutions and tips for making this incredibly flavorful and inclusive meal!

This post contains affiliate links.

Why This Allergy-Friendly Chicken Salad Sandwich Will Be Your New Favorite

Chicken salad sandwiches have always been a staple in my life – from quick lunches to elegant party fare, and easy weeknight dinners. However, even before navigating the world of food allergies, I often found traditional chicken salad to be a bit uninspired. Bland, lacking in texture, and missing that special something. This recipe changes all of that!

While I personally don’t have food allergies, my son’s dietary needs for gluten, dairy, and egg-free options led me to create this truly exceptional version. What started as a necessity has become a genuine family favorite, earning a regular spot in our dinner rotation. It’s not just “good for an allergy-friendly recipe”; it’s simply incredibly delicious and surprisingly easy to make!

The secret lies in a flavorful base infused with Dijon mustard and a thoughtful blend of spices, which elevates the humble chicken salad to a gourmet experience. Thanks to the remarkable advancements in egg-free and vegan mayonnaise, you can serve this to anyone – allergy-sufferer or not – and they’ll never suspect it’s free from common allergens. Prepare to rediscover your love for this classic sandwich!

Crafting a Gluten-Free Chicken Salad Sandwich: Bread & Beyond

The primary hurdle in making a chicken salad sandwich gluten-free is, naturally, the bread. While the filling itself is often naturally free of gluten, selecting the right bread or bun is crucial. Always double-check all ingredient labels to ensure no hidden gluten finds its way into your meal. Here are a variety of excellent gluten-free options to explore:

Our top pick for an all-around fantastic gluten-free bread, which also happens to be top-8-free and vegan, is Little Northern Bakehouse White Wide Slice. If you prefer to buy it locally rather than from Amazon, I often find it at health-focused grocery stores like Natural Grocer. They also offer buns, though these can be harder to find in some areas.
For those times you crave a bun, we highly recommend Schar’s Hamburger Buns or their delightful Schar’s Ciabatta Rolls (as pictured in this post). Do note that Schar products typically contain soy, which is an important consideration if you’re avoiding soy as well.
If you’re aiming for a **low-carb** option or simply want to skip the bread, transforming your chicken salad into a delicious lettuce wrap is a perfect solution. Large, crisp lettuce leaves make an excellent vehicle for the flavorful filling.
Alternatively, you can enjoy it as a sophisticated dip, pairing it with your favorite gluten-free crackers for a satisfying crunch.
Consider using gluten-free wraps for a portable and easy-to-handle meal, such as Mission Gluten-free Tortillas or BFree wraps. These are great for lunchboxes or picnics.
Finally, for a lighter, salad-style meal, serve your chicken salad over a bed of fresh spring mix, baby spinach, or other leafy greens. It makes for a vibrant and filling main course salad.

Effortlessly Dairy-Free: A Naturally Delicious Chicken Salad

While avoiding dairy can often present a significant challenge in many recipes, it’s surprisingly easy when it comes to chicken salad sandwiches. Traditional chicken salad fillings are typically dairy-free by nature, relying on mayonnaise, chicken, and fresh additions. You’ll rarely find dairy in the core components, though occasionally some recipes might add cheese – which is easily omitted. The main point of caution usually lies with the bread, ensuring it hasn’t been buttered or doesn’t contain dairy ingredients. As always, diligent label-checking for all ingredients, particularly for hidden dairy, is a must. You’ll find no special substitutions are needed for this recipe, as it’s naturally dairy-free and delicious as is!

Choosing the Best Egg-Free Mayo for Your Sandwich

For those needing an egg-free option, the quality of egg-free mayonnaise is absolutely paramount, and thankfully, it has come an incredibly long way! This recipe wouldn’t be possible without the excellent vegan mayo options available today. I’m quite discerning when it comes to mayonnaise, and I wholeheartedly recommend Hellman’s Vegan Mayo (also marketed as Best Food’s in some regions). It’s so good that it’s not just for this recipe; it’s my go-to for everyday use. You can typically find it at major grocery stores like Walmart and, of course, on Amazon.

For your peace of mind, here are the common ingredients in Hellman’s Vegan Mayo:

Sunflower oil, water, modified food starch (potato, corn), distilled vinegar, less than 2% of: sugar, salt, lemon juice concentrate, sorbic acid and calcium disodium EDTA (used to protect quality), natural flavor, paprika extract (for color).

Please remember to always check the product label at the time of purchase, as ingredient formulations can occasionally change.

An Allergy-Friendly Delight: Top-8-Free Assurance

Yes, this chicken salad sandwich is remarkably allergy-friendly! By carefully selecting your ingredients, particularly the bread and mayonnaise, this recipe can be entirely free of the top eight most common allergens. When you opt for Little Northern Bakehouse bread and Hellman’s Vegan mayo, your sandwich will be free from: wheat, gluten, dairy, egg, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, fish, and shellfish. This means it’s a fantastic Top-8-Free option, opening up the joy of a classic chicken salad sandwich to many more people who navigate various food sensitivities. Always, always, make it a habit to read every single label to confirm ingredients haven’t changed since this publication.

Choosing and Preparing the Perfect Chicken for Your Salad

When it comes to the chicken for your salad, flexibility is key – there’s truly no wrong answer! The beauty of chicken salad is that it works wonderfully with various types and preparations of chicken. Whether you’re using:

**Leftover chicken:** A fantastic way to utilize previous meals.
**Store-bought rotisserie chicken:** A time-saver that’s packed with flavor (Costco, we’re looking at you!).
**Chicken thighs:** Known for their rich flavor and moist texture.
**Chicken breasts:** Lean, versatile, and easy to cook.

I often turn to frozen chicken breasts for this recipe, using it as an opportunity to clear out my freezer. My preferred method is the Instant Pot: I place the frozen breasts with about 3/4 cup of water, a pinch of salt, and a dash of pepper. Cook on high pressure for 25 minutes, then allow a natural release for 10 minutes. Once done, I drain the liquid and easily shred the tender chicken. Feel free to use whichever chicken you prefer, what you have readily available, and what suits your schedule!

Making Your Chicken Salad Sandwich Nut-Free with a Satisfying Crunch

Many traditional chicken salad recipes incorporate walnuts or other tree nuts to add a delightful crunch. However, for families like mine dealing with tree nut allergies, this isn’t an option. Our simple yet incredibly effective substitution is **salted sunflower seeds**. They provide that essential, satisfying crunch and a lovely savory note without any concerns about nut allergies. Plus, they’re often more accessible and budget-friendly!

The Secret to a Deli-Style Chicken Salad Sandwich Experience

To truly elevate your chicken salad from homemade to “deli-quality,” two elements are crucial: a flavorful, well-seasoned base (beyond just plain mayo!) and a strategic blend of ingredients for texture and crunch. By incorporating contrasting flavors – something sweet like grapes, and something salty and crunchy like sunflower seeds – you achieve a sophisticated, balanced profile that tastes professionally made. Your guests will be asking if you catered it!

Here’s my winning combination of ingredients that creates that coveted deli-style experience:

Shredded chicken
Finely minced red onion for a sharp, fresh bite
Crisp celery, adding essential crunch
Egg-free/vegan mayo (or regular if no egg allergies) for a creamy base
Dijon mustard, a secret weapon for depth of flavor
Seasoned salt for an extra layer of savory taste
Garlic salt for aromatic complexity
Freshly ground black pepper to taste (I typically skip additional salt as my sunflower seeds are salted)
Shelled, salted sunflower seeds for that perfect nutty crunch without nuts
Sweet, seedless red grapes, halved or quartered, for a burst of juicy sweetness
Red leaf lettuce for serving, adding freshness and a subtle bitter note (optional)

One of the best parts about this recipe is its simplicity and reliance on pantry staples. It doesn’t require fresh herbs that you might not always have on hand, and I almost always have red onion and celery in my fridge, making it a perfect last-minute dinner solution when other plans fall through.

Popular Substitutions and Customization Ideas

This chicken salad recipe is incredibly versatile and forgiving, allowing for easy substitutions based on your preferences or what you have available. Feel free to experiment and make it your own!

**Fruit Swaps**: Instead of red grapes, many people enjoy sweet apples (diced), green grapes, or dried cranberries. Any of these options will provide that delightful touch of sweetness needed to balance the savory and salty elements.
**Onion Choices**: While I prefer red onion for its vibrant color and robust flavor, green onions (scallions) are another popular choice if you prefer a milder onion taste. Use whatever variety you enjoy most.
**Lettuce Options**: The type of lettuce you use for your sandwich or as a bed for the salad is entirely up to you. Butter lettuce, romaine lettuce, iceberg, or bibb lettuce all work well. (My own children often prefer to skip the lettuce altogether!)
**Seed Alternatives**: If sunflower seeds aren’t your preference, pumpkin seeds (pepitas) can be a fantastic alternative, offering a similar crunch and earthy flavor.

Essential Tools for Making This Gluten-Free Chicken Salad

Gathering your tools for this recipe couldn’t be simpler. You’ll only need a few basic kitchen items:

A sturdy cutting board
A sharp chef’s knife (or your favorite utility knife)
A large mixing bowl for combining ingredients
A large spoon for stirring everything together
Standard measuring cups and spoons

What to Serve Alongside Your Delicious Chicken Salad Sandwiches

Keeping things simple and stress-free is key, especially when feeding a family with young children. For us, this chicken salad sandwich pairs perfectly with easy side dishes that complement its flavors without adding extra fuss:

Classic French fries, crispy tater tots, or crunchy potato chips for a satisfying savory crunch.
A refreshing selection of fresh fruit and raw veggies (like carrot sticks or cucumber slices) to add color, nutrients, and lightness to the meal.

This effortless pairing is another reason why I adore this meal; it’s bold and flavorful yet requires minimal prep and cook time. If you’re looking for a more adventurous or robust side dish, you might also enjoy this Italian-inspired salad, which is also dairy-free and allergy-friendly.

Storing Leftover Gluten-Free Chicken Salad for Meal Prep

This recipe is excellent for meal prep! To maximize freshness and safety, always store your leftover chicken salad mixture separately from any bread. Transfer the chicken salad to an airtight container and keep it refrigerated. It will remain delicious for up to three days, making it perfect for quick lunches or dinners throughout the week.

Important Note: If you’re serving this at an event like a shower or luncheon, remember that perishable foods like chicken salad should not be left at room temperature for more than two hours to prevent bacterial growth.

Looking for More Allergy-Friendly Finger Foods for Your Next Gathering?

If you’re hosting a party or simply need a variety of gluten-free, dairy-free, and egg-free finger foods to complement your chicken salad sandwiches, explore these fantastic options:

Turkey Bacon Ranch Wraps
3 Ingredient Dairy Free Ranch Dip
Vegan Queso (also nut-free!)
Dairy-Free French Onion Dip
Asian Quinoa Meatballs
Italian Pulled Pork Sliders
4 Ingredient BBQ Chicken Sliders
Cranberry Salsa Dip
Chicken Salad Sandwiches (this very recipe!)
Gluten, Dairy, and Egg-Free BLTs
Sesame-Free Hummus (recipe found in my cookbook)

Tastiest Egg-Free Chicken Salad Sandwich

Yield:
10 Sandwiches

Prep Time:
15 minutes

Total Time:
15 minutes

If you miss chicken salad sandwiches because you can’t have gluten, dairy or eggs…I have a way you can still enjoy it. AND, it may just be better than you remember. With lots of texture and crunch and more than just plain mayo, this will be your new favorite way to enjoy this classic.

Ingredients

SALAD INGREDIENTS:

2 cups cooked chicken chopped–approx 2 chicken breasts (leftover or rotisserie works great!)
1/4 red onion, minced finely
1 stalk celery chopped
1/3 cup salted sunflower seeds, shelled
1/3 cup red seedless grapes, halved or quartered
Lettuce leaves (optional)
Your favorite gluten free vegan buns or bread (see post above for options)

DRESSING INGREDIENTS:

1/2 cup vegan mayonnaise (or regular if you can have eggs)
1 teaspoon Dijon mustard
1/2 teaspoon seasoned salt
1/2 teaspoon garlic salt
pepper to taste

Instructions

1. Use leftover chicken (instant pot, slow cooker, grilled, rotisserie–you name it, just about 2 chicken breasts worth) and shred it and add it to a large bowl.

2. Add the rest of your salad ingredients to the bowl.

3. In a small bowl, combine all of your dressing ingredients.

4. Add your dressing ingredients to your salad ingredients and stir to combine. Taste and adjust salt and pepper to your liking. (I find I only need to add pepper, not salt because of the salted sunflower seeds).

5. Toast your buns or bread. Place enough of the completed salad mixture on top of one side of the bread. Place a lettuce leaf on top (optional–my kids just pull it off, hence why it’s not in my photos) and then place to two pieces of bread together.

6. Serve immediately. Keep the salad mixture separate from the bread/buns if storing leftovers. Keep leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge 2-3 days (great for making ahead of time too!).

Notes

This salad is quite forgiving, so feel free to adjust the ingredients. If you like more crunch, add more celery or sunflower seeds. If you like it more creamy, add a little more mayo. It’s very flexible, so feel free to use the measurements as a guide, rather than a fixed amount.

If you’re looking for some other gluten, dairy and egg free dinners, check out my cookbook: An Allergy Mom’s Lifesaving Instant Pot Cookbook.

*Our allergies, while severe and that get re-tested yearly, are such that we can go strictly by what’s on the label. I do not call companies to see what things are derived from, or call manufacturers to see about potential cross contact. If your allergies require you to do so, please do your own homework. I cannot assure you of any ingredient’s safety, only you can do that. I simply share what works for our family

**If you are going to feed this to someone with food allergies, and you yourself do not have food allergies, I HIGHLY recommend having them check every single brand and ingredient you are using, to ensure they’re OK with each part of the recipe. And, to make sure you’ve talked to them about how to avoid cross contamination in your kitchen.

DON’T FORGET TO PIN THIS RECIPE! SAVE IT TO YOUR DIETARY-SPECIFIC PINTEREST BOARDS SO YOU CAN EASILY FIND IT LATER.